Concussions & Migraines 101
An evidence-based cheat sheet for the first 48 hours, what to do next, and what to ask your doctor about.
Why I wrote this
I wrote this 5 days after concussion #2 in three years. Concussion #1 happened when I got knocked off my bike by a car on Queen Street West in Toronto (Sept 2021). Concussion #2 happened on Father's Day when my (shockingly strong for a little guy) nephew kicked a soccer ball into the side of my head at close range.
A concussion is a type of mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) — a temporary brain function disturbance after a hit to the head or a body impact that makes your brain rapidly move. Symptoms can be physical, cognitive, emotional, and sleep-related.
My first round was a masterclass in how little guidance you can get in the real world: basically "rest and Tylenol." It took me two years to see a neurologist for concussion-related migraines. When I finally did, I got a practical supplement handout and a plan — and within ~6 weeks, my migraine episodes faded almost entirely.
When to go to the ER / call emergency services
These are "don't debate it" signs. Get urgent medical care.
- Worsening headache that doesn't go away
- Repeated vomiting
- Seizure / convulsions
- Increasing drowsiness, can't wake up, or can't stay awake
- Slurred speech, weakness, numbness, or decreased coordination
- Unusual confusion, agitation, or not recognizing people/places
- One pupil larger than the other or double vision
- Severe neck pain
Source: CDC "danger signs" list for concussion/mTBI. CDC Heads Up | CDC TBI symptoms
What to do in the first 48 hours
The old advice was: lie in a dark room until you become one with the dark room. The updated consensus is kinder and more effective: relative rest for ~24–48 hours, then gradual activity. Amsterdam Consensus statement
Practical version
- Protect your brain from a second hit. No sports, no risky activities, no "I'm fine" bravado.
- Keep stimulation low. Quiet environment, dim lights if light hurts, simple conversation, naps if needed.
- Screens: limit if they spike symptoms. Short checks are usually fine; doom-scrolling is not your rehab plan.
- Hydrate and eat like a functional adult (even if your brain wants gummy bears). Small bland meals if nausea is an issue.
- Pain control: acetaminophen is commonly used early; discuss NSAIDs with a clinician if unsure. Mayo Clinic
- Book follow-up. If symptoms are not improving in a few days, get reassessed.
Day 3 onward — what actually helps
1. Light aerobic exercise (sub-symptom threshold)
Evidence has shifted hard: strict rest until symptoms resolve is not beneficial for most people. Early, controlled aerobic exercise tends to speed recovery.
- Adolescent RCT: aerobic exercise recovered faster than placebo-like stretching (median 13 vs 17 days). PubMed
- Systematic review/meta-analysis: early prescribed exercise improved recovery by ~4.6 days on average. PubMed
Start with a gentle walk or stationary bike. If symptoms ramp hard, back off. The goal is "a little challenge," not "heroic suffering."
2. Vestibular rehab (if dizziness/vertigo/balance issues)
Vestibular rehabilitation (a type of physio) can help with dizziness, balance problems, and vestibular/ocular symptoms. Evidence is supportive, though studies vary. Meta-analysis
3. Post-traumatic headache / migraine pattern
Headache is the most common persistent symptom after concussion. If headaches are sticking around, ask about a structured plan. The American Headache Society has a clinical white paper on post-traumatic headache that lays out the framework clearly. PubMed
- Medication options to discuss (not for DIY): migraine preventives (e.g., nortriptyline/amitriptyline), migraine abortives (triptans), newer agents (gepants like ubrogepant).
- Non-drug options to ask about: acupuncture, biofeedback, neuromodulation devices (e.g., Cefaly, gammaCore) — these vary in evidence and availability.
When can I return to work/school?
There's a gray zone. You want to re-engage your brain… without punishing it. The consensus approach is stepwise: short blocks of cognitive work + breaks + gradual screen ramp-up. Amsterdam Consensus
A workable template
- Start small: 15–30 minute blocks, then rest.
- Increase by tolerance: add time if symptoms stay mild and don't spike later that day.
- Use accommodations: reduced hours, breaks, dimmer lighting, quiet workspace, speech-to-text, printed materials.
- If you crash the next day: that's data — dial it back.
Supplements — what's worth considering (and what to skip)
Honest framing: the supplement evidence for migraine prevention is stronger than for "speeding concussion recovery." But post-concussion headache often looks like migraine, and some supplements have limited concussion-specific data too.
Magnesium (400–600 mg/day)
- Migraine prevention evidence review (magnesium dicitrate 600 mg often cited). PubMed
- Acute concussion RCT in adolescents: oral magnesium improved symptom scores at 48 hours vs placebo. PubMed
Can cause diarrhea (especially citrate/oxide). If you have kidney disease, talk to a clinician first.
Riboflavin (B2) — 400 mg/day
- Classic migraine RCT (400 mg/day vs placebo). PubMed
- Systematic review/meta-analysis of riboflavin for migraine prophylaxis. PubMed
- Sport-related concussion RCT: riboflavin 400 mg/day associated with shorter recovery time. Contextual review
Melatonin — often 3 mg nightly (clinician-directed)
- Migraine prevention RCT: melatonin 3 mg better than placebo and similar efficacy to amitriptyline 25 mg, with better tolerability. PubMed
- Youth post-concussion syndrome RCT (3 mg and 10 mg doses studied). Full text
- Neuroimaging correlates paper in pediatric PPCS. PubMed
Can cause next-day grogginess. If you drive early mornings, test on a weekend first.
CoQ10 — 300 mg/day
- Migraine RCT (100 mg three times daily) showed benefit vs placebo. Full text
- Systematic review/meta-analysis on CoQ10 migraine prophylaxis. BMJ Open
Omega-3s (EPA + DHA)
Biologically plausible for brain inflammation/cell membrane support, but human concussion outcomes evidence is not settled. Take with realistic expectations.
- Example clinical trial in concussion. PubMed
If you're on blood thinners or have bleeding issues, talk to your clinician first.
Choline / Citicoline (CDP-choline)
Complicated. Smaller studies and some meta-analyses suggest possible benefits, but large high-quality trials in TBI have been mixed. If budget is tight, this is not the first spend.
- Citicoline systematic review & meta-analysis (2017). PubMed
Butterbur (Petasites hybridus) — not recommended anymore
Butterbur used to be recommended for migraine prevention (2012 AAN/AHS guideline), but the American Academy of Neurology stopped recommending it in 2015 due to serious liver toxicity concerns.
- NIH NCCIH summary (AAN stopped recommendation in 2015). NCCIH
- American Headache Society: "Butterbur is no longer a recommended treatment for migraine." AHS
Even if it works for some people, safety + product-quality issues make it a hard pass.
Evidence links — the short list
- Amsterdam international concussion consensus statement (2023): BJSM | PubMed
- CDC concussion danger signs: CDC Heads Up
- Early exercise speeds recovery (adolescent RCT): PubMed
- Early exercise meta-analysis (~4.6 days faster): PubMed
- Oral magnesium acute concussion trial: PubMed
- Vestibular rehab meta-analysis: PubMed
- AHS white paper on post-traumatic headache in youth: PubMed
- Butterbur safety: NCCIH
If any link breaks, search by the PubMed ID or article title — journals love moving URLs around.